Introduction to Points of Clarification

By: Young Seol, Brown University 2014

Points of Clarification, more commonly known as POCs, are questions the Opposition team asks the Government team after case construct has been read but before the start of the actual Prime Minister’s Constructive (or PMC). According to a new rule, timing for the PMC generally does not start until after case construct has been read and POCs have been asked, although you may occasionally see people time the reading of case construct and stop time only for POCs.

On rare occasions, you may find it necessary to ask POCs outside of the commonly accepted time period. This can happen, for example, if a particularly nebulous point made during the PMC prompts further clarification of Gov’s case, or, more commonly, if Opp decides to countercase and fails to properly elucidate the details thereof. Regardless of the specific circumstances, teams may (but seldom do) ask POCs during the PMC or LOC by rising and verbally stating, “Clarification.” It is considered good practice for the debater currently speaking to stop time and accept the question.

Although rare, if your partner is asked a POC, you are generally allowed to answer it in his or her stead, at the risk of costing your partner some speaker points. Still, this is not a meaningful penalty in outrounds, and, even during inrounds, is generally preferable to your partner insufficiently answering the question posed to them. Truly prepared debaters should never need to use this privilege.

Points of Clarification: Basics

Most fundamentally, POCs are necessary to clarify nebulous aspects of Gov’s case. A case like “Presidents should have a single, six-year term” probably requires fewer POCs than a hypothetical that takes two minutes to explain. You can also ask Gov to repeat certain portions of case statement that you may have missed. In addition, many cases are incomplete. If Gov says, “Abolish the government,” it raises the questions of how the government is being abolished and what, if anything, they hope will happen afterwards. Finally, certain cases may involve unfamiliar topics: constitutional law, politics, and economics are the most common ones. For such cases, you should use POCs to understand the background as necessary. For example, you can ask about prior precedents if Gov runs that a Supreme Court case was wrongly decided.

You should also be using POCs to clarify your position in the round. If necessary, questions like “What exactly are we defending?” or “If we argued this, it would be in line with our position, right?” can be used. Additionally, it is often important to clarify the merits by which the round will be adjudicated: Who is the actor in question? (Policy questions have different answers based whether you’re arguing from a government’s perspective or based on the impact to society; e.g. China’s censorship laws.) How should the arguments be weighed? (For example, is it strictly a matter of constitutional law, or is the round about what is normatively better?) This will help prevent the Government team from putting new burdens on you in the MG. Especially if you feel a case might be tight, doing so can also either help you find some ground to work with, or bolster your arguments should you choose to pull the trigger on a tight call.

When in doubt, it is also generally a good strategy to ask more questions than fewer; this also has the benefit of giving the LO more time to prepare his or her off-case arguments. However, be careful not to abuse this strategy and, when on Gov, be willing to call out teams that do so; judges will usually be receptive to you cutting POCs short in such instances.

Points of Clarification: Strategy

As you improve in debate, POCs become much more important, and oftentimes the right questions or wrong answers will decide the round before it has even begun. As Gov, POCs should be considered a crucial part of the PMC; you should be entirely prepared for any possibly relevant question they might ask you.

Shrewd Opp teams will generally have a strategy in mind after hearing case construct and ask you POCs to try to trap you into a position weak to it. As a real-life example, in NYU 2012 Semifinals, the Government team ran “The NFL should allow teams to sell shares.” Opp asked the POC, “Do these shares have voting rights?” and then countercased with “The NFL should allow teams to sell shares without voting rights” when Gov answered yes. As Gov, when faced with such a POC, it can sometimes be advantageous to say, “We aren’t going to take a stance on that,” while other times you may prefer to take a specific position. In fact, many times, you may simply wish to say “That’s irrelevant” in response to a POC. It depends on the case and, as such, is something you should consider while casing.

As Opp, you will obviously want to employ similar strategies yourself. You are allowed to talk with your partner while asking POCs (but, again, take care not to abuse this privilege, as it slows down the round considerably), which can help you formulate a strategy around which to ask specific questions. A common tactic in high-level debate is to leave critical arguments out of the PMC for the MG, to make the case seem more open in the event of a tight call or give Opp less time to respond to them. If you can foresee such arguments, asking the appropriate POCs can force the issue earlier, thereby strengthening your position on it.

On the flip side, while POCs can be used to narrow the ground Gov has to work with and clean up the round, they may also be inadvertent ways for Gov to sneak in new caveats about their case, thereby giving you less to work with. In such instances, it may be advantageous to not ask a POC and simply assume the worst about their case and force the MG to spend precious time clarifying. This effectively gives them only one speech to make that clarification and, given the strength of the Opp block (the 13 minutes, including grace, of the combined MO and LOR), often forces the PMR to engage with the case as you interpreted it. As an example, if Gov’s case is “Send troops to Syria,” then you can argue about the harms of long-term Syrian occupation. As an alternative to this strategy, you can ask “bright line” POCs, which force Gov to draw a specific line that they are not willing to cross. In the above example, “Would you be willing to occupy Syria, or will you pull out once you’re done?” Such POCs can be used to try to trap Gov or make their plan seem less efficacious.

Finally, and most importantly, this article is merely a primer on POC basics and common strategies, and it is not intended to be a definitive guide. As with every aspect of debate, it is paramount that you pay attention to your judge’s reactions, as individual preferences vary; this will provide insight into when it’s reasonable to cut off POCs, whether your POCs are being too long-winded, etc. Additionally, don’t regurgitate the advice given in the article. Rather, try to absorb it and utilize it in a way that you are comfortable with. No particular style of debate is correct, particularly when it comes to Points of Clarification: what’s most important to your competitive success is finding one that works for you.

928 thoughts on “Introduction to Points of Clarification

  1. Pingback: Google
  2. Pingback: huge dildos
  3. Pingback: Hoverboard Go Kart
  4. Pingback: DILAUDID 8 MG
  5. Pingback: best clit vibrator
  6. Pingback: keltec sub 2000
  7. Pingback: krt disposable
  8. Pingback: krt disposable
  9. Pingback: gamma labs website
  10. Pingback: travel vibrators
  11. Pingback: best sex toys
  12. Pingback: Cannabis Oil
  13. Pingback: sex education
  14. Pingback: meritroyalbet
  15. Pingback: meritking
  16. Pingback: madridbet
  17. Pingback: meritroyalbet
  18. Pingback: elexusbet
  19. Pingback: meritroyalbet
  20. Pingback: meritroyalbet
  21. Pingback: Glock 20 price
  22. Pingback: colt python 2020
  23. Pingback: baymavi
  24. Pingback: baymavi
  25. Pingback: lottovip
  26. Pingback: tombala siteleri
  27. Pingback: male masturbator
  28. Pingback: meritroyalbet
  29. Pingback: eurocasino
  30. Pingback: tiktokdownloader
  31. Pingback: fulgurite for sale
  32. Pingback: acpspectrum
  33. Pingback: PS5 for Sale
  34. Pingback: bitcoin card
  35. Pingback: penis vacuum pump
  36. Pingback: glo carts
  37. Pingback: buprenorfine
  38. Pingback: app for pc
  39. Pingback: pc games download
  40. Pingback: oscar mayer
  41. Pingback: Herbal Incense
  42. Pingback: madridbet giriş
  43. Pingback: custom cereal box
  44. Pingback: glock 28
  45. Pingback: Uganda tours
  46. Pingback: PC hilfe lachen
  47. Pingback: business in canada
  48. Pingback: Real krt
  49. Pingback: scrap cars
  50. Pingback: BERETTA 92FS
  51. Pingback: CZ P10C FOR SALE
  52. Pingback: madritbet
  53. Pingback: meritroyalbet
  54. Pingback: eurocasino
  55. Pingback: elexusbet
  56. Pingback: eurocasino
  57. Pingback: eurocasino
  58. Pingback: eurocasino
  59. Pingback: eurocasino
  60. Pingback: eurocasino
  61. Pingback: eurocasino
  62. Pingback: penis sleeve
  63. Pingback: Restaurant
  64. Pingback: carrefour
  65. Pingback: eurocasino
  66. Pingback: scrap car pick up
  67. Pingback: thrusting vibrator
  68. Pingback: visit podcast
  69. Pingback: Latest News
  70. Pingback: Haupia strain
  71. Pingback: Bubble hash
  72. Pingback: Moroccan hash
  73. Pingback: Litto
  74. Pingback: Bubble hash
  75. Pingback: eurocasino
  76. Pingback: bahis siteleri
  77. Pingback: 1ordinary
  78. Pingback: meritroyalbet
  79. Pingback: lawert.micro.blog
  80. Pingback: kawers.micro.blog
  81. Pingback: buy cialis cheap
  82. Pingback: cialis
  83. Pingback: buy cialis cheap
  84. Pingback: buy cialis online
  85. Pingback: kalwer.micro.blog
  86. Pingback: buy cialis
  87. Pingback: buy cialis cheap
  88. Pingback: canadian cialis
  89. Pingback: Northwest Pharmacy
  90. Pingback: buy viagra delhi
  91. Pingback: buy viagra uk
  92. Pingback: A片
  93. Pingback: porno}
  94. Pingback: pornoizle}
  95. Pingback: pharmacy
  96. Pingback: meriking
  97. Pingback: buy viagra pills
  98. Pingback: buy viagra usa
  99. Pingback: online drug store
  100. Pingback: canadian drug
  101. Pingback: what is stromectol
  102. Pingback: buy stromectol
  103. Pingback: stromectol online
  104. Pingback: stromectol scabies
  105. Pingback: ivermectina dosis
  106. Pingback: canadian viagra
  107. Pingback: buy viagra now
  108. Pingback: buy generic viagra
  109. Pingback: pharmacy
  110. Pingback: buy viagra now
  111. Pingback: madridbet
  112. Pingback: canadian cialis
  113. Pingback: canadian rx
  114. Pingback: canadadrugs
  115. Pingback: stromectol generic
  116. Pingback: stromectol reviews
  117. Pingback: facts stromectol
  118. Pingback: stromectol doses
  119. Pingback: meritking
  120. Pingback: canada pharmacy
  121. Pingback: canadian drugstore
  122. Pingback: canadadrugs
  123. Pingback: grandpashabet
  124. Pingback: canadian pharmacys
  125. Pingback: canadian drugstore
  126. Pingback: canadian viagra
  127. Pingback: canadian pharmacy
  128. Pingback: canada drug
  129. Pingback: Grandpashabet
  130. Pingback: grandpashabet
  131. Pingback: canadian rx
  132. Pingback: buy viagra usa
  133. Pingback: madridbet
  134. Pingback: fuck google
  135. Pingback: fuck google
  136. Pingback: pharmacy canada
  137. Pingback: okey oyna
  138. Pingback: fuck google
  139. Pingback: Beverly Bultron
  140. Pingback: canada pharmacy
  141. Pingback: madridbet
  142. Pingback: canadian rx
  143. Pingback: drugs for sale
  144. Pingback: pharmacy canada
  145. Pingback: madridbet
  146. Pingback: canadian viagra
  147. Pingback: www.dibiz.comgdooc
  148. Pingback: canada rx
  149. Pingback: ギャンブル
  150. Pingback: pharmacy canada
  151. Pingback: canadian drug
  152. Pingback: Chirurgie Tunisie
  153. Pingback: Chirurgie Tunisie
  154. Pingback: meritking
  155. Pingback: canada rx
  156. Pingback: canadian drug
  157. Pingback: madridbet
  158. Pingback: Higher education
  159. Pingback: Higher education
  160. Pingback: MIS courses
  161. Pingback: Global Cultures
  162. Pingback: meritking giriş
  163. Pingback: Faculty Grievances
  164. Pingback: digital press
  165. Pingback: MBA in FUE
  166. Pingback: grandpashabet
  167. Pingback: meritking
  168. Pingback: meritking
  169. Pingback: madridbet
  170. Pingback: buy viagra usa
  171. Pingback: Northwest Pharmacy
  172. Pingback: grandpashabet
  173. Pingback: сука пари
  174. Pingback: meritking
  175. Pingback: child porn
  176. Pingback: Admissions process
  177. Pingback: fue
  178. Pingback: distance education
  179. Pingback: porn
  180. Pingback: meritking
  181. Pingback: meritking
  182. Pingback: grandpashabet
  183. Pingback: meritking
  184. Pingback: Vacuum pumps
  185. Pingback: meritking giriş
  186. Pingback: grading system
  187. Pingback: engineering jobs
  188. Pingback: Prof. Ebada Sarhan
  189. Pingback: grandpashabet
  190. Pingback: izmir escort
  191. Pingback: grandpashabet
  192. Pingback: sms onay
  193. Pingback: steroid satın al
  194. Pingback: child porn
  195. Pingback: child porn
  196. Pingback: ozempic
  197. Pingback: hacklink
  198. Pingback: xxlargeseodigi
  199. Pingback: child porn
  200. Pingback: mediprime
  201. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  202. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  203. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  204. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  205. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  206. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  207. Pingback: porn
  208. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  209. Pingback: Hooled strip led
  210. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  211. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  212. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  213. Pingback: child porn
  214. Pingback: porn
  215. Pingback: shipping broker
  216. Pingback: estddos
  217. Pingback: Freight Broker
  218. Pingback: clima para mañana
  219. Pingback: porn
  220. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  221. Pingback: jute rugs
  222. Pingback: seo in Canada
  223. Pingback: bitcoin
  224. Pingback: swimsuit for women
  225. Pingback: porn
  226. Pingback: bewerto
  227. Pingback: porn
  228. Pingback: pennsylvania clima
  229. Pingback: best mobile phone
  230. Pingback: future university
  231. Pingback: future university
  232. Pingback: future university
  233. Pingback: buy tiktok likes
  234. Pingback: multisbo rtp
  235. Pingback: wix seo
  236. Pingback: porn
  237. Pingback: Fiverr.Com
  238. Pingback: lean manufacturing
  239. Pingback: Warranty
  240. Pingback: Piano relocation
  241. Pingback: FUE
  242. Pingback: FUE
  243. Pingback: FUE
  244. Pingback: FUE
  245. Pingback: FUE
  246. Pingback: FUE
  247. Pingback: Moving assistance
  248. Pingback: Commercial moving
  249. Pingback: Reliable movers
  250. Pingback: Classic Books 500
  251. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  252. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  253. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  254. Pingback: çeşme transfer
  255. Pingback: sex
  256. Pingback: Speaker
  257. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  258. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  259. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  260. Pingback: partners
  261. Pingback: izmir travesti
  262. Pingback: frenchie puppies
  263. Pingback: Sport analysis
  264. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  265. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  266. Pingback: live sex cams
  267. Pingback: live sex cams
  268. Pingback: live sex cams
  269. Pingback: live sex cams
  270. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  271. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  272. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  273. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  274. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  275. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  276. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  277. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  278. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  279. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  280. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  281. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  282. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  283. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  284. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  285. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  286. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  287. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  288. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  289. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  290. Pingback: hakkari escort
  291. Pingback: güngören escort
  292. Pingback: girne escort
  293. Pingback: giresun escort
  294. Pingback: Diyet Yolu
  295. Pingback: Diyet Yolu
  296. Pingback: gezginizm
  297. Pingback: Moda Danışmanı
  298. Pingback: Yeni Başlayanlar
  299. Pingback: edremit escort
  300. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  301. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  302. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  303. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  304. Pingback: serialebi qaerulad
  305. Pingback: business
  306. Pingback: demre escort
  307. Pingback: Kuliah Termurah
  308. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  309. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  310. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  311. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  312. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  313. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  314. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  315. Pingback: Opel Oto Çıkma
  316. Pingback: Opel Oto Çıkma
  317. Pingback: Blog
  318. Pingback: Blog
  319. Pingback: hd porno izle
  320. Pingback: porno
  321. Pingback: porno
  322. Pingback: istanbul travesti
  323. Pingback: porn
  324. Pingback: izmir travesti
  325. Pingback: Porn
  326. Pingback: yasam ayavefe
  327. Pingback: kralbet
  328. Pingback: porno sikis
  329. Pingback: sms onay
  330. Pingback: sms onay
  331. Pingback: glucotrust legit
  332. Pingback: cheap sex cams
  333. Pingback: steroid
  334. Pingback: steroid
  335. Pingback: sms onay
  336. Pingback: canine probiotics
  337. Pingback: porno izle
  338. Pingback: child porn
  339. Pingback: grandpashabet
  340. Pingback: porn
  341. Pingback: live sex cams
  342. Pingback: grandpashabet
  343. Pingback: dehydrated water
  344. Pingback: frt trigger
  345. Pingback: grandpashabet
  346. Pingback: efos y edos
  347. Pingback: 늑대닷컴
  348. Pingback: Slot Barat
  349. Pingback: superslot
  350. Pingback: allgame
  351. Pingback: 918kiss
  352. Pingback: หวย24
  353. Pingback: Makeup sets
  354. Pingback: grandpashabet
  355. Pingback: pg slot
  356. Pingback: porno izle
  357. Pingback: child porn
  358. Pingback: AI Attorney
  359. Pingback: cybersécurité
  360. Pingback: mobil odeme bozum
  361. Pingback: grandpashabet
  362. Pingback: forum
  363. Pingback: cratosroyalbet
  364. Pingback: megagame
  365. Pingback: 17 wsm
  366. Pingback: 35 whelen ammo
  367. Pingback: 25-06 ammo
  368. Pingback: 7mm-08 ammo
  369. Pingback: child porn
  370. Pingback: itsMasum.Com
  371. Pingback: itsMasum.Com
  372. Pingback: film pirater
  373. Pingback: nang tanks
  374. Pingback: nangs sydney
  375. Pingback: website
  376. Pingback: itsmasum.com
  377. Pingback: travesti.site
  378. Pingback: chatiw
  379. Pingback: porn
  380. Pingback: casino porna
  381. Pingback: child porn
  382. Pingback: garap
  383. Pingback: proporno
  384. Pingback: itsmasum.com
  385. Pingback: child porn
  386. Pingback: ricnirpltaei
  387. Pingback: cinrripletaie
  388. Pingback: porn
  389. Pingback: porn
  390. Pingback: joker gaming
  391. Pingback: johannesburg jobs
  392. Pingback: delhi jobs
  393. Pingback: porn
  394. Pingback: porn
  395. Pingback: porn
  396. Pingback: Kod Bulutu
  397. Pingback: vassycalvados.fr
  398. Pingback: child porn
  399. Pingback: child porn
  400. Pingback: betgross giriş
  401. Pingback: Poliçe Paneli
  402. Pingback: child porn
  403. Pingback: child porn
  404. Pingback: child porn
  405. Pingback: jojobet
  406. Pingback: jojobet twitter

Leave a Comment