West Point 2014 Semifinals: AU A v. Harvard/Hopkins

Case: Does the majority of interpersonal violence arise from the general conditions of the natural world or something unique to humans? Opp chose general conditions of the natural world.

Gov: AU A
PM: Ashe Girard
MG: Dan Cobos

Opp: Harvard/Hopkins
LO: Nathaniel Donahue
MO: David Israel

[expand title=””Results”” notitle=””true”” trigclass=””arrowright””]AU A won on a 3 – 0 decision.[/expand] 

262 thoughts on “West Point 2014 Semifinals: AU A v. Harvard/Hopkins

  1. This case is designed to provoke all of these persuasive OPP arguments and still win by staying focused on the troubling question of how we can explain mass-genocide and atrocity with naturalistic and evolutionary arguments, with the obvious strategic move of focusing on the fact that genocide and purges simply account for more inter-person violence and so if they are uniquely human GOV wins. The PMR emphasizes the simplicity of the strategy by honing in on this clash, simply calling attention to the fact that purges and concentration camps are beyond the pale, terrible to an extreme no one ever saw coming and a phenomenon that seems terribly irrational and all-too human in its use of ideology and hatred. Though the Opp does some fantastic debating in this round the central thesis that genocide is a uniquely human creation fueled by language and ideology seems irrefutably true at the beginning of the debate and remains that way at the end, and so it is easy to vote GOV on magnitude.

    It is easy to see the more persuasive and more technically refined debaters as winning but some times a series of clever arguments do not amount to proving the central thesis of your position.

  2. Yeah, opp had no chance in the round because they utterly failed to engage with the question of what sources result in the most violence and just assumed that there’s some kind of amorphous “violence” they get to talk about

  3. Replace opp with gov and you’ve got an accurate statement. Pretty sure in all opp speeches that I heard specific instances of violence were warranted (rise in ideology driven by scarcity, international conflicts driven by resource disparities). When opp literally coopts all of gov ground by the end of MO, and gov doesn’t even contest it, there’s no way a gov vote makes any sense.

  4. I skimmed parts of the round: did Opp bring up the observation that the murder rate among humans is VASTLY lower than that of most natural predators such as lions and tigers? Human intellect decreases violence on the aggregate; it does not increase it. That’s why we live in the least violent era in human history, and why advanced societies tend to be more peaceful than their third world counterparts.

    1. It’s definitely possible that things unique to humans hugely decrease violence that would otherwise have been caused by natural conditions, but that of the violence that occurs in the modern day more of it is caused by unique human elements than by natural conditions (even if only because unique human things pre-empted the influence of natural conditions)

  5. With all due respect to Dan, it doesn’t seem like he understood the evolution point at all, or even what the theory is. Did he just deny that the emotion of hatred comes from Evolution?

  6. Opp should have won. Maybe the judges got confused by the arguments that Gov made and gave them the benefit of the doubt. To an inexperienced debater/judged they may seem technical. In reality they were incoherent.

  7. Pingback: Beverly Bultron
  8. Pingback: Finance job market
  9. Pingback: MBA degree Cairo
  10. Pingback: Economics
  11. Pingback: Hardness Tester
  12. Pingback: Future University
  13. Pingback: programs
  14. Pingback: smart systems
  15. Pingback: faculty of dental
  16. Pingback: Simulation Models
  17. Pingback: MSc in pharmacy
  18. Pingback: fue contact
  19. Pingback: MBA in FUE
  20. Pingback: liv pure
  21. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  22. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  23. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  24. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  25. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  26. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  27. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  28. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  29. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  30. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  31. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  32. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  33. Pingback: red boost
  34. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  35. Pingback: weather
  36. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  37. Pingback: grey frenchie
  38. Pingback: french bulldog
  39. Pingback: french terrier
  40. Pingback: exotic bully
  41. Pingback: bernedoodles
  42. Pingback: dog kennel
  43. Pingback: jute vs sisal rug
  44. Pingback: blogging
  45. Pingback: isla mujeres
  46. Pingback: french bulldog
  47. Pingback: future university
  48. Pingback: future university
  49. Pingback: future university
  50. Pingback: future university
  51. Pingback: future university
  52. Pingback: multisbobet
  53. Pingback: fue
  54. Pingback: lean six sigma
  55. Pingback: Warranty
  56. Pingback: Piano maintenance
  57. Pingback: FUE
  58. Pingback: Classic Books 500
  59. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  60. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  61. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  62. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  63. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  64. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  65. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  66. Pingback: Coach
  67. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  68. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  69. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  70. Pingback: partners
  71. Pingback: flowforce max
  72. Pingback: Betting
  73. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  74. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  75. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  76. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  77. Pingback: live sex cams
  78. Pingback: live sex cams
  79. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  80. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  81. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  82. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  83. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  84. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  85. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  86. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  87. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  88. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  89. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  90. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  91. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  92. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  93. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  94. Pingback: Bilona
  95. Pingback: sns
  96. Pingback: Slot Thailand
  97. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  98. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  99. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  100. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  101. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  102. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  103. Pingback: cheap sex cams
  104. Pingback: fullersears.com
  105. Pingback: fullersears.com
  106. Pingback: live sex cams
  107. Pingback: freeze dried candy
  108. Pingback: marketplace
  109. Pingback: frt trigger
  110. Pingback: 늑대닷컴
  111. Pingback: Deposit
  112. Pingback: nang delivery
  113. Pingback: allgame
  114. Pingback: 918kiss
  115. Pingback: หวย24
  116. Pingback: Korean beauty
  117. Pingback: pg slot
  118. Pingback: cybersécurité
  119. Pingback: Life Coach Chelsea
  120. Pingback: megagame
  121. Pingback: electronic visa
  122. Pingback: sicarios
  123. Pingback: SaaS Attorney
  124. Pingback: itsMasum.Com
  125. Pingback: itsMasum.Com
  126. Pingback: itsMasum.Com
  127. Pingback: nangs sydney
  128. Pingback: chauffe eau Tours

Leave a Comment